Skip to main content
Notes
table of contents
Index
- Affymetrix, 117, 257
- African American Diversity Project, 308–9
- African American Heart Failure Trial (AHeFT), 304, 309
- African Americans: as HGP donors, 110; as PDR donors, 111; pharmacogenomics and, xxix, 304, 309; precision medicine and, 309; rejection from genetic research, 298; sickle cell disease among, 299
- Ahitav, Nadav, 87
- AI (artificial intelligence). See Artificial intelligence
- Albayrak, Gulsah, 191n6
- Alberts, B., 481
- Algorithms, xxx, 24, 267, 283–87, 451, 456, 461, 465
- All of Us program (Precision Medicine Initiative), 218, 273–74
- Alta Conference (1984), 124–25
- American College of Medical Genetics, 234, 243
- American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 234
- American Indians. See Native Americans
- American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA), 81, 445
- American Society for Human Genetics (ASHG), 64, 330
- Amsterdamska, Olga, 343
- Ancestry testing, 120–21, 237, 324
- Animal modeling, 353, 356–62, 365–66
- Ansorge, Wilhelm, 175
- Anthropomorphism, 371n12
- ARRA (American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009), 81, 445
- Artificial intelligence (AI), 284–85
- Asbury, K., 388–89
- ASHG (American Society for Human Genetics), 64, 330
- Austin, Robert, 136–37
- Bacterial Artificial Chromosomes (BACs): definition of, xlivn2; homologous clones from DNA libraries, 74; libraries used for sequencing, xxxvi–xxxviii, xliv, xlivn2, 233, 269; sequencing cost curve and, 53, 55, 59
- Bailey, M. H., 487
- BAP (Biotechnology Action Programme), 164
- Barbujani, G., 303
- Barker, A. D., 447
- Barker hypothesis, 354
- Barsh, G. S., 387
- Baylor College of Medicine Human Genome Sequencing Center, 119, 161, 187, 444
- Behavioral epigenetics, 362–64
- Behavioral genetics, xliii, 5, 318–19, 323, 331, 388–89
- Behavioral genomics, xliii, 240, 322, 331
- Beijing Genomics Institute (BGI), xxix, 119
- Bell Curve, The (Murray & Herrnstein), xxviii
- Bellenson, Joel, 330
- Bermuda Principles, 9, 11, 187, 253–54
- Beta-thalassemia, 92–93
- BiDil (heart failure drug), 309
- Big data: biobanks and, 276; in biomedicine, 286; cancer genomics and, xxiii, 441, 461; as data-centric research, 462; letting the data lead, 442, 461; scientific publishing and, 146, 147
- Big science, xviii, xix, xxxv–xxxvi, 264, 471, 479–81
- Binet, Alfred, 391–92
- Biobanks: big data and, 276; electronic health records and, 274–76, 278; emergence of, 270–71; pharmacogenomics and, 284; population-scale, 273, 275–76; precision medicine and, 271, 273, 274; private health systems and, 272–73; research clinics and, 271–72, 274, 286–87; sequencing costs and growth of, 218
- Biochemical proxy strategy, 407, 414–15, 417–23, 426, 428–29, 432n11, 433n22
- Bioethics, xxviii, 5–6, 14, 229, 231–33, 242, 298
- Bioinformatics: for aggregation of data, xli; Department of Energy and, 6; functional genomics and, 416–17; in HGP research effort, 16, 35; polymorphisms distinguished from errors using, 259; resource centers and, 175; sequencing cost curve and, 54, 55; TCGA Project and, 487
- Biological embedding, 348, 349, 354, 361
- Biologism, 366–68
- Biomedical and Health Research program (BIOMED), 174, 175, 193n15
- Biomedicine: big data in, 286; Eurocentrism in, 308; nanotechnologies useful to, 137; race in, 294, 298, 303, 307, 308, 310–11. See also Epigenetics
- Bionano Genomics, 66, 137
- Biopolitics, 340–41
- Biotechnology Action Programme (BAP), 164
- Birney, Ewan, 95, 149, 153–54
- Black-box paradigm, 344–49, 368
- Blair, Tony, 160
- Blumenbach, Johann Friedrich, xxx
- Blumenthal, David, 231
- Bobrow, Martin, 195n27
- Bodmer, Walter, 177, 187–89, 296
- Boem, F., 475
- Bogaert, A. F., 321
- Bohr effect, 380
- Botstein, David, 166–67
- Boyer, Herbert, 166
- Boyle, A. P., 424
- Branton, Daniel, 138–39
- Brenner, Sydney, 183
- Broad heritability, 393
- Broad Institute (MIT/Harvard), 119, 323–25, 329, 444
- Brooks, A. N., 433–34n22
- Caenorhabditis elegans: cell identification, 195n25; genome sequencing of, 22–23, 165, 183–84, 188, 195n27; modENCODE and, 80–81, 419–20, 424, 432–33n15; modERN Project and, 433n20; physical mapping of, 183, 184
- Campbell, Eric, 231
- Campbell, Phillip, 149
- Cancer and cancer genomics: algorithms and, 285; big data and, xxiii, 441, 461; chromosomal abnormalities and, 464n4; clinical sequencing for, 218; as common-complex disease, 196; as “discovery” science, 449–50; driver genes and mutations in, 442–43, 447–48, 450–51, 455–63, 464n2, 465nn7–8, 484; epidemiology and, 344, 370n7; epigenetics and, 448; epistemic structure of, 473; extra-genomic factors in, 448, 463; genetic testing for, 234; heterogeneity of genomes, 449, 454, 458–60, 462–63, 465n6; research types in, 464n1; sequencing process in, 450–51; structural variants and, 137, 223n9, 451; targeted therapies for, 445–47, 449, 464n3
- Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) Project, The, 441–63; ARRA funding and, 445; challenges of, 452–55, 462, 463; contextual considerations, 442; cost point per genome for, 212–13; as data-driven vs. hypothesis-driven science, 441–43, 460–62; data production in, 59, 213, 223nn9–10; as epistemically centralizing project, 478, 483, 494; goals and objectives of, 445–49, 483, 484, 492; insights gained from, 213–14; Karenina paradox and, 454–60; as large-scale facilitator project, 492, 494; precision medicine and, 443; publications from, 153, 443, 445, 449, 487; research on new genes discovered by, 473, 487–93; research questions associated with, 214, 486, 487; sample considerations, 448–53, 464–65n5, 484–85, 496n18; as scaffolding future research, 442–43, 460; scientific background of, 450–54; team science approach of, 446; tumor sequencing project as origins of, 443–45
- Candidate cis-regulatory elements (cCREs), 80, 83
- Cantor, Charles, 138
- Cao, Han, 137
- Carugati, F., 390
- Catalogue of Somatic Mutations in Cancer (COSMIC), 446
- Causal narratives, 475, 495n7
- Causal role (CR) account of function, 407–11, 413, 431n9
- Cavalli-Sforza, Luigi Luca, 297, 298, 312n9
- CCDGs (Centers for Common Disease Genomics), 46, 60–61, 63, 216
- cCREs (candidate cis-regulatory elements), 80, 83
- CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention), 236, 312n6
- CDCV (common disease, common variant) hypothesis, xxix, 114
- cDNA. See Complementary DNA
- CEER (Centers of Excellence) Program, 231, 240–41, 308
- CEGS (Centers of Excellence in Genomic Science), 135–36
- Celera Genomics: BAC libraries used by, xlivn2; draft sequence and, 158, 160, 190n2, 300, 479; establishment of, 257, 479; IHGSC rivalry with, xviii, 163; public contest with, xviii, xxv, xxxix, 29; racial diversity initiatives, 300–301; Science publication of human genome paper, 151; user-inclusive networks and, 193n17; Venter as CEO of, 160, 190n2, 300–301, 479
- Cell (journal), 443, 445, 458
- Centers for Common Disease Genomics (CCDGs), 46, 60–61, 63, 216
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 236, 312n6
- Centers of Excellence in Genomic Science (CEGS), 135–36
- Centers of Excellence (CEER) Program, 231, 240–41, 308
- Centre for the Study of Human Polymorphism (CEPH), 115, 176–77
- Chakravarti, Aravinda, 295, 300, 302
- Chen, Z. X., 423
- Cho, Mildred, 231
- Chromatin-Immuno-Precipitation coupled to high-throughput sequencing (ChIP-seq), 417–18, 433n18
- Chromatin-Immuno-Precipitation coupled to microarray analysis (ChIP-chip), 420, 433n18
- Chromosome workshops, 168–73, 177, 185–87, 192–93n13, 196n30
- Chronic diseases, 343, 345, 346, 354, 486
- Clinical Genome Resource (ClinGen), 282
- Clinical Sequencing Exploratory Research (CSER) Consortium, 242–43, 281–82
- Clinton, Bill, 159–60, 187, 302
- Cloud computing, 89, 283
- Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats (CRISPR), 378, 385, 388, 397
- Cohen, Daniel, 176
- Cohen, Stanley, 166
- Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory (CSHL), 42, 165, 168, 172, 313n18, 478
- Collins, Francis: ENCODE Project and, 73, 95–96; Genetic Variation Program and, 111; as NCHGR/NHGRI director, xvii–xviii, 11, 29, 159–60, 300, 444–45, 479; as NIH director, xxiii, 186; Polymorphism Discovery Resource and, 300; TCGA Project and, 444–45, 447
- Common-complex diseases, 196n31, 216–17, 223n13, 269
- Common disease, common variant (CDCV) hypothesis, xxix, 114
- Comparative genomics, 74, 209–12, 220, 222nn4–5, 415
- Complementary DNA (cDNA), xvii, 14, 55, 59, 71, 163, 180–82, 194nn21–22
- Confidentiality. See Privacy issues
- Consent: for data sharing, 90–91, 112, 116; failure to obtain, xxxvii, 24; informed, xxviii, xliv, 236–37, 239
- Constitutive skin color, 386
- Contextual developmental construction, 382–83, 399
- Conversion therapies, 328
- Cook-Deegan, Robert, xxv
- Cooperative agreements, 26, 31–32, 36, 45, 73, 85, 95
- Coriell Institute for Medical Research, 111, 116
- Corsaro, Cheryl, 128
- COSMIC (Catalogue of Somatic Mutations in Cancer), 446
- Cost curve. See Sequencing cost curve
- Cox, Edward (Ted), 136–37
- CR (causal role) account of function, 407–11, 413, 431n9
- Craighead, Harold, 136–37
- Crick, Francis, 183
- CRISPR (Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats), 378, 385, 388, 397
- CRISPR-Cas9 technologies, 88, 232
- CSER (Clinical Sequencing Exploratory Research) Consortium, 242–43, 281–82
- CSHL. See Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory
- Cummings, Dominic, 388
- Curd, M., 473
- Cystic fibrosis, xxvii, 168, 223n11, 234, 299
- Davenport, C. B., 385
- Davenport, G. C., 385
- Davis, B. D., 480
- Davis, Ronald, 166–67
- Deamer, David, 138–39
- deCODE genetics, 73, 97n1, 271
- DeLisi, Charles, 478
- Demographic Rule (FDA), 303
- Deoxyribonucleic acid. See DNA
- Department of Energy (DOE): Alta Conference convened by, 124–25; on cost estimate for genome projects, 42; ELSI Program for, 228, 229, 231; Health and Environmental Advisory Committee, 17, 229; Human Genome Diversity Project and, 296; Joint Genome Institute of, 161, 187; NIH collaboration with, 6–7, 14, 17, 30, 35, 126; research participant guidance from, xxxvii; technology development and, 6, 479; on women in genetic research, 299. See also Human Genome Project
- Department of Health and Human Services, 37n2, 42, 295, 298, 313n20
- Ding, Li, 443–45, 453–54
- Direct-to-consumer (DTC) genetic testing, 273, 284
- Discovery strategies, 473–78, 495nn4–5
- Discrimination: ELSI Program priorities on, 296; in employment, xxviii, 232; Eurocentrism, 297, 300, 308; genetic information as basis for, xxviii, 232, 235; sexual orientation and, 324–25, 330. See also Racism
- Diseases: chronic, 343, 345, 346, 354, 486; common-complex, 196n31, 216–17, 223n13, 269; Mendelian, 215, 218, 223n11, 273, 286; noncommunicable, 348, 370n6
- DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid): biochemical features of, 86; cDNA, xvii, 14, 55, 59, 71, 163, 180–82, 194nn21–22; discovery of structure of, 161, 183, 188, 191nn4–5; junk, 196n31, 381, 430n3; methylation of, 87, 354, 363, 417; recombinant, 164, 166; transcription into RNA, 71, 76, 417, 418. See also Biobanks; Genetics; Genome sequencing
- DOE. See Department of Energy
- Donors: for BAC libraries, xxxvii; for biobanks, 271–74; for ENCODE, 90; for HapMap Project, 115–16; for HGP sequencing phase, 24, 110, 233, 270, 299; for Polymorphism Discovery Resource, 112, 300; privacy issues and, 116, 118, 299, 300; for sexual orientation study, 324
- Draft sequence: Celera and, 158, 160, 190n2, 300, 479; completion of, xvii, xxxii, 26–27, 286, 302, 479; definition of, xlivn1, 52; estimated vs. actual cost of, 62; IHGSC and, 158, 160, 162, 177, 187, 264; publication in Nature, xxxix, xl, 145, 150–51, 160–63, 177, 187, 191n3, 264; sequencing centers in generation of, 25, 27, 160, 161, 191n3; White House ceremony for celebration of, xxxii, 27, 159–60, 302
- Drell, Dan, 254–55
- Drosophila melanogaster: genome sequencing of, 22, 165; Mendelian patterns of inheritance in traits of, 381; modENCODE and, 80–81, 419–24, 432–33n15, 433–34n22
- DTC (direct-to-consumer) genetic testing, 273, 284
- Duchenne muscular dystrophy, 223n11
- Dulbecco, Renato, 447, 478
- Dunham, Ian, 153–54
- Dunston, Georgia, 308–9
- Duster, Troy, 238
- Ecker, Joseph, 87
- Eddy, S. R., 491
- EEC (European Economic Community), 163–66, 172
- Eichler, Evan, 250, 260, 261
- Eisenberg, Rebecca, 231
- Electronic health records (EHRs), 242, 266–67, 274–79, 283, 284
- Electronic Medical Records and Genomics (eMERGE) network, 218, 277–81, 283, 284
- ELSI Program. See Ethical, Legal, and Social Implications Program
- EMBL (European Molecular Biology Laboratory), 159, 175, 177, 193–94n18
- Encyclopedia of DNA Elements (ENCODE) Project, 70–96; ARRA funding and, 81–82; background of, 70–73, 121, 431n10; biological assays and data types for, 74, 75; communication strategies and, 75, 85; community publications, 78, 79, 92; Consortium organization and membership, 84–92; Consortium publications and community outreach, 75–83, 91–92, 430–31n3; controversy involving, 406–8, 421, 430–31n3, 431n7; cooperative agreements and, 73, 85, 95; criticisms of, 78–80, 406, 421, 431nn4–5; Data Analysis Center for, 77, 81–83, 95; Data Coordination Center for, 76–77, 81, 83, 88; data management and, 76–77, 88–89; data release and accessibility issues, 89–91; data standards development and, 89; ENCODE 1 (pilot phase), 71–76, 84–87, 89–91, 94, 131, 419, 432n12, 433n17; ENCODE 2, 76–82, 86, 87, 90, 95–96, 153, 419–21; ENCODE 3, 82–83, 86, 87, 90, 405; ENCODE 4, 83–84, 87, 88, 90–91, 94, 96, 405, 432n11; ENCODE Portal, 86, 88–89; end goal of creating “complete” catalog, xxi, 94–95; External Consultants Panel for, 85; future outlook for, 96; hallmark features of, 84–96; impact on research, 92–94; importance of common targets, samples, or reagents, 88; interactions with other genomics projects, 86, 90; lessons learned from, 95–96; mouse ENCODE, 82, 89, 92, 433n16; naming considerations, 73, 97n2; Nature publications related to, 77–78, 153–54; open-source software sharing and, 91; proxy strategies and, 414–19, 429; target sequences selected for analysis, 74–75; technology development and, 73, 77, 82, 85–88, 131; transparency and, 76, 80, 89. See also Model Organism Encyclopedia of DNA Elements (modENCODE) Project
- Energy Department. See Department of Energy
- Environmental epigenetics, 350, 353, 362, 363
- Epidemiology: biobanks and, 273; biological evidence in, 342–49; biopolitics and, 340, 341; black-box paradigm and, 344–49, 368; cancer and, 344, 370n7; “from cells to society” approach and, 340–43, 347; integration of epigenetics into, 347–50, 366–68; pragmatic argument for, 346–47; in simulation of low SES via stress induction, 356–58; in simulation of parental care via pup licking, 358, 360; in simulation of war or childhood poverty via starvation, 354–56; “the social” in, 349–53, 358, 362; statistical nature of, 355–56; strategic argument for, 346, 347. See also Social epidemiology
- Epigenetics: behavioral, 362–64; biological embedding and, 348, 349, 354, 361; biologism and, 366–68; cancer progression and, 448; emergence of, 347, 382, 400; environmental, 350, 353, 362, 363; integration into epidemiology, 347–50, 366–68; maternal immune mechanism and, 321; nutritional, 354–55; origins of term, 370n9; phenotypic plasticity and, 367; physiological stress response and, 356; sexual orientation and, 321; social, 340–42, 353–54; “the social” in, 353–54, 362, 363; style of reasoning specific to, 365–66
- Escherichia coli, 22, 165, 206, 380
- ESF (European Science Foundation), 193–94n18
- ESTs (expressed sequence tags), xvii, 10, 182, 185
- Ethical, Legal, and Social Implications (ELSI) Program, 227–44; Centers of Excellence Program, 231, 240–41, 308; clinically focused studies by, 234–35, 241–43; conceptual foundation for, 231–32; controversy involving, xviii, 227, 229; donor-related issues addressed by, 233; eMERGE network and, 278; establishment of, 227–29, 231; future outlook for, 243–44; genetic testing and, xxviii, 234, 296; Genetic Variation Program and, 109, 111; HapMap Project and, xxviii, 114, 116, 238–40; history of projects supported by, xxvii–xxviii, 294, 296; interdisciplinary collaboration and, 235, 238; Juengst as head of, 5–6, 231, 232; 1000 Genomes Project and, 240; policy-research debate within, 229–31; productive tensions and, 228, 231, 235, 243–44; race studies funded by, 299, 301–2, 312–13n13; SER Consortium and, 282; on stored tissue samples, 235–37; Watson’s proposal for creation of, xxvii, 5, 228
- Eugenics: Galton as founder of, 391; genetic enhancement and, 379, 384, 385, 399, 400; genomic medicine and, xxix; intelligence and, 388, 389, 397; legacy of, xliii, xliv, 232; liberal, 389, 392, 401nn2–4; moderate, 401n2; persistence in genetics and genomics, xliii, 5; positive, 379, 400; predictive techniques of genetic medicine and, 173; stigma associated with, 167
- Eumelanin, 384, 386–87
- Eureka consortium, 191–92n8, 194n20
- Eurocentrism, 297, 300, 308
- European Bioinformatics Institute, 95, 116, 153
- European Commission: BIOMED program and, 174, 175, 193n15; Biotechnology Action Programme of, 164; Eureka consortium and, 191–92n8; on genome mapping and sequencing, 159, 174, 189; NIH communication with, 28; research and development policies of, 164, 165, 167; yeast genome sequencing and, 163–65, 172–74. See also Human Genome Analysis Programme
- European Economic Community (EEC), 163–66, 172
- European Gene Mapping Project (EUROGEM), 175–76, 178–80
- European Molecular Biology Laboratory (EMBL), 159, 175, 177, 193–94n18
- European Science Foundation (ESF), 193–94n18
- Evolutionary proxy strategy, 407, 414–17, 420, 423, 426, 428–29, 432n11
- Expressed sequence tags (ESTs), xvii, 10, 182, 185
- Eye color, genetics of, 384–86, 388
- Facultative skin color, 386
- FCCs (Functional Characterization Centers), 83, 87, 88
- FDA (Food and Drug Administration), 303, 304, 446
- Federal Grants and Cooperative Agreements Act of 1977, 45
- Females. See Women
- Ferguson-Smith, Malcolm, 173, 192–93n13
- Fetal Origins Hypothesis, 354
- FICV problem. See Functional Identification, Characterization, and Validation (FICV) problem
- Flynn effect, 392
- Food and Drug Administration (FDA), 303, 304, 446
- Ford, E. B., 249
- Fortun, Michael, 172, 192n11
- Foster, Morris, 238
- Fraternal birth order effect, 321, 322
- “From cells to society” approach, 340–43, 347, 362, 364, 369, 369n2, 370n5
- Fruit fly. See Drosophila melanogaster
- Functional absence, 412, 413
- Functional ambiguity, 411–13
- Functional Characterization Centers (FCCs), 83, 87, 88
- Functional genomics, 405–30; bioinformatics and, 416–17; challenges of, 405–6; CR account of function, 407–11, 413, 431n9; definition of, 405, 430n1; from-theory-to-practice assumption in, 407, 408, 410, 435n31; power and limitations of, 408; practical issues in, 408; proxy strategies in, 406–7, 412–23, 426, 428–30, 432n11, 433–34n22; SE account of function, 407, 409–14, 416, 431nn6–8; theoretical problems in, 408. See also Encyclopedia of DNA Elements (ENCODE) Project; Model Organism Encyclopedia of DNA Elements (modENCODE) Project
- Functional Identification, Characterization, and Validation (FICV) problem, 405–15, 417–19, 421–23, 427–30
- Functional parasitism, 412, 413, 417
- Funding opportunity announcements (FOAs), 126–28, 132–35, 137, 139, 209–10, 215
- Futuyma, Douglas, 249
- Gadney, Max, 154
- Galton, Francis, 391
- Ganna, A., 319, 321–25, 328–32
- Gannett, Lisa, 250, 261
- Garvey, Clare, 154
- Gefitinib, 445–47
- GenBank, 24, 250–51, 253, 270
- Gender: confusion regarding, 328; hair color and, 386; IQ tests and, 392; public health disparities and, 294; reflexive dimension of, 352. See also Women
- Gene editing: CRISPR-based, 378, 385, 388, 397; germline editing, 232, 378–79, 384, 385; specificity and, 379, 384. See also Genetic enhancement
- Genentech, 166
- Gene specificity, 379, 384, 385, 397, 401n1
- Gene therapies, 92–93
- Généthon, 19, 176, 180, 187, 189, 194nn19–22
- Genetic counseling, xxvii, 267–68
- Genetic determinism, 327, 333, 388
- Genetic engineering, 164, 167, 183
- Genetic enhancement: of complex behavioral traits, 388–97, 399; ELSI Program and, 232; ethical issues of, 379, 384; eugenics and, 379, 384, 385, 399, 400; of physical traits, 384–88
- Genetic exceptionalism, 227, 229, 235, 236, 243
- Genetic information: as clinical tool, 281; discrimination based on, xxviii, 232, 235; ELSI Program and, xxvii, 227, 232, 234; equal access to benefits of, 232; functional genomics and, 405; genetic exceptionalism and, 235, 236; integration into clinical practice, 234; selling back to consumers, 273. See also Privacy issues
- Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act of 2008 (GINA), xxvii–xxviii, 232
- Geneticization, defined, 333
- Genetic mapping: chromosome workshops and, 168, 170, 173; circumscription of datasets for, xxxiv; EUROGEM and, 175, 176; GESTEC funding for, 18–19; lessons learned during, 20; NRC on desirability of, 13; team science approach to, 20; technology development and, 126, 128
- Genetic proxy strategy, 407, 414, 415, 419, 433–34n22
- Genetic reductionism, xxxi, 191, 318, 379, 381–82
- Genetics: behavioral, xliii, 5, 318–19, 323, 331, 388–89; of eye color, 384–86, 388; of hair color, 386; of intelligence, 388–89, 392–93, 395–97; Mendel’s patterns of inheritance, 381, 384, 400; persistence of racism and eugenics in, xliii, 5; population, 109, 208–9, 249, 319; of sexual orientation, 318, 320–25, 328–33; of skin color, 386–88; social life of, 333; statistical, 109. See also Epigenetics; Medical genetics
- Genetic testing: ancestry testing, 120–21, 237, 324; clinical guidelines for use of, 234; for cystic fibrosis, xxvii, 234, 299; direct-to-consumer, 273, 284; ELSI Program and, xxviii, 234, 296; for sickle cell anemia, 299
- Genetic Variation Program, 109–21; background of, 109–10; ELSI Program and, 109, 111; HapMap Project and, 113–18; motivations for establishment of, 110; 1000 Genomes Project and, 118–20; Polymorphism Discovery Resource and, 110–12; uses of variation data, 120–21; on variants across the genome, 112–13
- Genome mapping: European Commission support for, 159, 174; technology development and, 126, 128, 131, 138; Wellcome Trust and, 159, 172. See also Genetic mapping; Physical mapping
- Genome Science and Technology Centers (GESTECs), 18–19, 127–30
- Genome sequencing: Advisory Committee for, 23–24, 26, 36; BAC libraries used for, xxxvi–xxxviii, xliv, xlivn2, 233; budget for, 34–35, 46, 47; cDNA strategy for, 180–82; of C. elegans, 22–23, 165, 183–84, 188, 195–96n27; completion of high-quality sequence, 14, 27, 191n5; cost tracking for, 34, 43–51, 65–66, 203–20, 222n3, 224n16; cottage industry approach to, 166, 174, 188; data release policies, 9–10, 23, 25, 26, 37; of D. melanogaster, 22, 165; error rate in, xxxiv, 251–56, 260; GESTEC funding for, 19; nanopore, 134, 138–39; pilot project period, 23–25, 33, 206, 252–53; production metrics for, 44–46, 55–60; public sector effort, xviii, xxv, xxxix, 22–29; quality control measures for, 22–24, 33–34; resequencing, 34, 49, 53, 120, 205, 253, 256; single-molecule approach, 138; structure of discovery in, 221, 224n19; technology development and, xxii, xxiv, 41, 125–29, 134, 138–39; of yeast, xviii, 53, 163–67, 172–74, 184, 188, 191n7, 192n9. See also Draft sequence; Next-generation sequencing (NGS) platforms; Sequencing centers; Sequencing cost curve
- Genome Sequencing Program (GSP), 46, 51–52, 60–61, 220
- Genome-Wide Association Studies (GWAS): common disease studies, 216, 223n12; development of robustness in, xxx; genomic medicine and, 268–69, 277, 278; HapMap Project and, xxix, 113, 114, 118, 120, 209; on intelligence, 393, 395–97; linkage disequilibrium and, 121; on loci associated with skin color, 386; 1000 Genomes Project and, 118, 120; on sexual orientation, 318, 320–32; single nucleotide polymorphisms and, 93, 257, 321–22
- Genome-wide polygenic scores (GPSs), 396–99
- Genomic 5 (G5) sequencing centers, xxxviii, 161–63, 174, 177, 182, 187, 191n3, 195n24
- Genomic information: access to data, 149; algorithms as translators of, 284; as clinical tool, 266, 279–81, 286, 287; division between producers and users of, 174; in electronic health records, 242, 279; ELSI Program and, 227, 234; genetic exceptionalism and, 227, 236; growth in volume of, 154; integration into clinical practice, 234
- Genomic literacy, 419, 432n14
- Genomic medicine, 264–88; algorithms and, 267, 283–87; building blocks of, 266–67; cancer therapies and, 445–46, 464n3; diagnostic and therapeutic decision-making in, 276–82; Genome-Wide Association Studies and, 268–69, 277, 278; medical promises of HGP and, 264–70, 282, 378; NHGRI division of, 241, 267, 276–77, 280–82; personalized, xxix, 268, 271, 274, 276, 382; pharmacogenomics and, xxix, 269, 279, 284–85, 303–5, 309, 313n17; racist and eugenicist concerns in, xxix; socioeconomic disparities in access to, 281. See also Biobanks; Precision medicine
- Genomics: acceleration of, 162, 218; behavioral, xliii, 240, 322, 331; comparative, 74, 209–12, 220, 222nn4–5, 415; complete vs. comprehensive project aims, xxxviii–xlii; as discovery science vs. hypothesis-driven science, xxii, 220–21, 224n20; distributed approach to, 163, 188; FICV problem in, 405–15, 417–19, 421–23, 427–30; improvement of human health through, 84; medical genetics, relationship with, 158; Nature’s relationship with, 145, 151, 155; origins of term, 169; persistence of racism and eugenics in, xliii; pharmacogenomics, xxix, 269, 279, 284–85, 303–5, 309, 313n17; postgenomics, xxvi, xxxi–xlii, 163, 189, 340–41; scientific advancements in, 41, 45; social, xliii, 319, 322, 331; structural, 405, 430n1; systems biology and, 495n8. See also Cancer and cancer genomics; Epigenetics; Functional genomics
- Genomics (journal), 169, 172
- Genoscope, 176–77, 194n19
- Genotype-Tissue Expression (GTEx) project, 86, 90
- Genzentrum, 194nn21–22
- Germline editing, 232, 378–79, 384, 385
- Gerstein, M. B., 424
- Gert, Bernard, 232
- GESTECs (Genome Science and Technology Centers), 18–19, 127–30
- Gilbert, Walter, 478, 482–83
- Gillborn, D., 391
- GINA (Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act of 2008), xxvii–xxviii, 232
- Goffeau, André, 165, 167, 172
- Goldstein, A., 303
- Gottesman, Michael, xvii, 10
- Gould, S. J., 390–91
- Govindan, R., 452, 456
- GPSs (genome-wide polygenic scores), 396–99
- Greeley, Henry, 298
- Green, Eric, xliv, 72, 74, 430–31n3
- Green, Phil, xviii, 33, 251, 253, 255–56, 260–62
- GSP (Genome Sequencing Program), 46, 51–52, 60–61, 220
- GTEx (Genotype-Tissue Expression) project, 86, 90
- Gunter, Chris, 150
- Guyer, Mark, xxxvii, 4, 72, 95–96
- GWAS. See Genome-Wide Association Studies
- Habitus, defined, 363
- Hacking, I., 365
- Hair color, genetics of, 386
- Hamers, Dean, 318, 322, 329
- Haplotypes: definition and description of, 112; linkage disequilibrium and, 112–14, 119, 208; 1000 Genomes Project and, 119, 120; SNP Consortium and, 305–6. See also International HapMap Project
- HapMap. See International HapMap Project
- HD (hypothetico-deductive) system, 475
- Health and Environmental Advisory Committee (HERAC), 17, 229
- Health and Human Services Department. See Department of Health and Human Services
- Healy, Bernadine, xvii, xxvii, 10–11
- Herceptin (trastuzumab), 284, 446
- Heritability, 249, 320, 393–96, 398, 399
- HGAP. See Human Genome Analysis Programme
- HGDP. See Human Genome Diversity Project
- HGP. See Human Genome Project
- Hilgartner, Stephen, 160, 161, 166, 177, 478
- Hogben, L., 399
- Homosexuality. See Same-sex sexual behavior
- Howard Hughes Medical Institute, 7, 28, 172
- HUGO. See Human Genome Organization
- Human Gene Mapping Workshops, 159
- Human genome: block structure of, 113, 114; complexity of, 479, 496n12; euchromatic portion of, xxxix–xl, xlivn1, 14, 258, 260; heterochromatic portion of, xxxix, 110; near invariance from cell to cell, 94; number of base pairs in, 33, 47–48, 253; protein-coding genes encoded in, 71, 192n10; viewed as property of all mankind, 9
- Human Genome Analysis Programme (HGAP): cDNA sequencing strategy and, 180–82; chromosome workshops organized by, 173, 185, 187, 192–93n13; distributed approach of, 163, 188; establishment of, 158, 162, 172–73; European Data Resource and, 176; funding for, 173, 174, 193n15; goals and objectives of, 158, 162, 173, 174, 189; HGP and IHGSC compared to, 159–63; overshadowed by draft sequence, 158, 162, 191n6; on patenting practices, 195n24; Reference Library System and, 177; resource centers and, 175–76, 180–83, 189; user-inclusive networks and, 174–77, 180
- Human Genome Diversity Project (HGDP), xxix–xxxi, 114, 116, 239, 296–99
- Human Genome Organization (HUGO), 7, 28, 172, 187, 192n11, 192–93n13, 196n29, 296
- Human Genome Project (HGP): accomplishments of, 14–15, 19–20; Advisory Committee for, 7–8; ancillary activities in, 16, 35; beginnings of, xxiii, 3–4, 13–14, 17, 124–25, 161, 294, 478–79; Bermuda Principles on, 9, 11, 187, 253–54; challenges related to, xxi, 4–11, 15–16; completeness in description of goals for, xxxviii, xxxix–xl; complex features of, xviii–xix, xxxiv–xxxv, xlii, 16; contingent nature of, xvii–xix, xxxiii, xxxv, xlii; controversies involving, xviii–xix, xxv–xxvi, xxxv–xxxviii, xlii; criticisms of, 4–5, 15–16, 30, 78, 250, 265, 297, 381, 479–81; error standard for, 250, 253–55, 260–61; Eurocentrism in, 297, 300; finished sequence produced by, 52, 62, 250–51; five-year plans for, 9, 17, 25, 30, 35–36, 70, 126, 230, 295–96, 301, 479; funding committed to, 174, 295; input from outside experts, 15, 17, 36; international collaboration on, 7, 20, 22, 28, 160, 479; as large-scale facilitator project, 478, 482–83, 494; leadership considerations, 28–29; lessons learned during, 20, 27–37; medical promises of, 264–70, 282, 378; Nature publications related to, xxxix, xl, 160–62, 191n3; plurality of perspectives regarding, xix–xxi, xxv–xxxi, xlii; racial diversity initiatives, 299–301, 305; reductionism and, xxvi, xxviii–xxxi, xxxiii–xxxv, 381; sequencing cost curve and, 51–53, 62; technology development and, 8, 16, 29, 32, 35, 124–35, 139. See also Ethical, Legal, and Social Implications Research (ELSI) Program; Genome mapping; Genome sequencing
- Human Genome Sciences, 182
- Human Heredity and Health in Africa Project, 309
- Huntington’s Disease, 7, 168
- Hurst, C. C., 385
- Hutter, Carolyn, 448–51, 464n4
- Hygienist movement, 346, 370n8
- Hypothesis generation, 473–77, 485–86, 494
- Hypothetico-deductive (HD) system, 475
- IHEC (International Human Epigenome Consortium), 86, 89
- IHGSC. See International Human Genome Sequencing Consortium
- Illumina, 48–50, 55–59, 61, 65–66, 87, 117, 119, 275
- Illuminating the Druggable Genome Consortium (IDG), 493
- Imperial Cancer Research Fund (ICRF), 176, 177, 180, 187, 189
- Implementing Genomics in Practice (IGNITE) Network consortium, 280–81, 283, 284
- Informed consent, xxviii, xliv, 236–37, 239
- Institute for Genome Research, The (TIGR), 181–82
- Institutional facts, 352–53
- Intellectual property, xxviii, 117, 231, 241. See also Patents
- Intelligence, xxvii, 384, 388–93, 395–97, 399
- International Cancer Genomics Consortium, 446
- International HapMap Project (HapMap): CDCV hypothesis and, xxix, 114; community consultation in, 116, 239; complete vs. comprehensive aims of, xl, xli; complex features of, xxxiv–xxxv; continental grouping of races by, xxix; cost point per genome for, 207–8; Data Coordination Center for, 116; data release policies for, 117; deterministic nature of, xxxiii; ELSI Program and, xxviii, 114, 116, 238–40; Genetic Variation Program and, 113–18; Genome-Wide Association Studies and, xxix, 113, 114, 118, 120, 209; insights gained from, 208–9; interactions with other genomics projects, 86; proxy strategies and, 434n30; race and, xxxi, 293, 306–7; research questions associated with, 208, 209; selection of populations for inclusion in, 114–16; single nucleotide polymorphisms and, 113–14, 117, 118, 257; working groups for, 116–17
- International Human Epigenome Consortium (IHEC), 86, 89
- International Human Genome Sequencing Consortium (IHGSC): Celera rivalry with, xviii, 163; charitable funding within, 195n24; completeness as defined by, xxxix–xl; on completion of high-quality genome sequence, 14, 191n5; draft sequence completed by, 158, 160, 162, 177, 187, 264; Hilgartner on emergence of, 160; on protein-coding genes encoded in human genome, 71
- International Mouse Phenotyping Consortium, 493
- IQ tests, 390–92
- Laboratory of Molecular Biology of Cambridge (LMB), 183, 184
- Lander, Eric, xxiii, xxxvi, 222n3, 294, 302, 306
- Large-scale biology projects: as big science, 471, 480, 481; as epistemically centralizing, 470, 473, 478, 481, 483, 494; as facilitators, 470, 472, 477, 478, 482–83, 492, 494; impact on molecular biology, 470–73, 477–78, 481–82, 494
- Large-Scale Sequencing and Analysis Centers (LSACs): annual review of, 35; funding for, 25, 46, 161, 166, 186; progress reports from, 53–55, 59; sequencing cost curve and, 47, 51, 53–60, 62; top down approach of, 187–88; yeast genome sequencing and, 166–67. See also specific sequencing centers
- Lawrence, M. S., 459–60
- LD. See Linkage disequilibrium
- Lee, E. S., 422
- Legal implications of research. See Ethical, Legal, and Social Implications (ELSI) Program
- Lehrach, Hans, 177, 180
- Leng, G., 495n7
- Leng, R. I., 495n7
- Leonelli, S., 462
- Ley, Tim, 452, 453, 457–58, 465nn8–9
- Liberal eugenics, 389, 392, 401nn2–4
- Link, Daniel, 458
- Linkage disequilibrium (LD), 112–14, 117–19, 121, 208, 258
- Linkage mapping. See Genetic mapping
- Linnaeus, Carl, 383, 441
- Lipman, David, 10
- LMB (Laboratory of Molecular Biology of Cambridge), 183, 184
- LSACs. See Large-Scale Sequencing and Analysis Centers
- Machine learning, 284–85
- Markel, Howard, 232
- Marker papers, 84, 88, 90, 94, 149, 449, 451, 453
- Maroñas, O., 386
- Massively parallel reporter assays (MPRAs), 87, 432n11
- Maternal immune mechanism, 321
- Max Planck Institute for Human Genetics, 119, 303
- McGill University (Canada), 191n7, 192n9
- McKusick, Victor, 169, 172
- Medical genetics: chromosome workshops and, 168–69, 172–73, 185, 192–93n13; common-complex diseases and, 196n31, 216–17, 223n13, 269; European community and, 162, 167–69, 172; expressed sequence tags and, 182; genomics, relationship with, 158; institutional base of, 167–68; integration into clinical practice, 234, 235; Mendelian diseases and, 215, 218, 223n11, 273, 286; predictive techniques of, 173
- Melanin, 384–87
- Mendelian diseases, 215, 218, 223n11, 273, 286
- Merton, Robert, xxiv
- Messenger RNA (mRNA), xvii, 482
- Meyerson, Michael, 444, 454–55
- Micklos, David, 232
- Microarray data, 147–48
- MicroRNA, 420, 448
- Model Organism Encyclopedia of DNA Elements (modENCODE) Project, 419–29; ARRA funding and, 81–82; Consortium publications, 81; Data Analysis Center for, 81–82; data management and release policy, 89–90; establishment of, 76, 80, 407, 431–32n10; impact on research, 92, 432–33n15, 434nn28–29; investigative goals of, 419, 432–33n15; phase 1 (biochemical traces), 420–21, 429, 433n19; phase 2 (abstract principles of genomic function), 423–24, 427–29, 434nn25–26; proxy strategies and, 415, 419–23, 426, 428–30, 433–34n22; selection of organisms for, 80–81, 419, 434n23; theoretical tension and, 425–29, 434n27; timeline in relation to ENCODE phases, 419, 420; validation of elements, 421–23, 428, 433n21, 433–34n22
- Model Organism Encyclopedia of Regulatory Networks (modERN) Project, 433n20
- Moderate eugenics, 401n2
- Molecular biology: biopolitics and, 340; causal narratives in, 475, 495n7; data production grants and, 130; discovery strategies in, 473–78, 495nn4–5; epistemic independence of labs, 473, 481, 483; ethos of, 185, 480; explanatory power of, 348; foundational moment within, 161; “from cells to society” approach and, 340–43, 347, 362; hypothesis generation phase in, 473–77, 485; impact of large-scale biology projects on, 470–73, 477–78, 481–82, 494; knowledge culture in, 470, 471, 481; paradigm of, 479, 496n11; reductionism and, 380–81; in simulation of low SES via stress induction, 356–58; in simulation of parental care via pup licking, 358–60; in simulation of war or childhood poverty via starvation, 354–56; as small science, 470–73, 480, 483, 485, 493; social epidemiology and, 341; of social position, 358, 362; uncertainty regarding large-scale biology projects, 471
- Monod, J., 380
- Morgan, Michael, 159, 186
- Morgan, Thomas Hunt, 381
- Mouse Encyclopedia of DNA Elements (mouse ENCODE) Project, 82, 89, 92, 433n16
- MPRAs (massively parallel reporter assays), 87, 432n11
- mRNA (messenger RNA), xvii, 482
- Mueller-Wille, S., 480
- Mugny, G., 390
- Muscular dystrophy, 223n11
- Mutation calling, 450–54
- Myers, Richard, 130–31
- Nagel, T., 362
- Nakamura, Yusuke, 115
- Nanopore sequencing, 134, 138–39
- National Academy of Sciences (NAS), 22, 29, 42–43, 160
- National Advisory Council for Human Genome Research (NACHGR), 17, 25, 72–74, 76, 83, 135–36, 229
- National Cancer Institute (NCI), 212, 442, 452, 483. See also Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) Project, The
- National Center for Advancing Translational Science, 493
- National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI), 10, 111, 116, 488
- National Center for Human Genome Research (NCHGR): Collins as director of, xvii, 11; evolution of OHGR into, 3, 37n2, 43, 139n1; Gottesman as acting director of, xvii, 10; Jordan as deputy director of, xvii; mapping phase of HGP and, 19; organizational structure of, 4; original branches of, xxvii; required input from NACHGR, 17; on women in genetic research, 299. See also Human Genome Project; National Human Genome Research Institute; Office for Human Genome Research
- National Genographic Project, 309, 313n23
- National Heart Lung and Blood Institutes TOPMed program, 216
- National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI): close management of research activities, 31–33; Collins as director of, xvii–xviii, 11, 29, 159–60, 300, 444–45, 479; comparative genomics projects, 209–10, 222n4; complete vs. comprehensive project aims of, xxxix–xli; cooperative agreements and, 26, 31–32, 36, 45; evolution of NCHGR into, 3, 11, 37n2, 43, 139n1; flexibility of approach, 29–30, 45; FOAs issued by, 126–28, 132–35, 137, 139, 209–10, 215; Genetic Variation Program, 109–21; Genome Sequencing Program, 46, 51–52, 60–61, 220; genomic medicine division, 241, 267, 276–77, 280–82; Green as director of, xxiii; History of Genomics Program at, xviii, xx, xxiii–xxiv, xliii, xliv, 266; Jordan as deputy director of, xvii, 127; lessons learned during HGP, 27–37; mapping phase of HGP and, 19–20; Oral History Collection, 266; organizational complexity of, xviii, xix, 27; racial diversity initiatives, 299–300, 302, 308; required input from NACHGR, 17, 25; scope of collaborative network, 41–42; sequencing phase of HGP and, 22–27; tumor sequencing project sponsored by, 443–45. See also Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) Project, The; Encyclopedia of DNA Elements (ENCODE) Project; Human Genome Project; International HapMap Project; National Center for Human Genome Research; Office for Human Genome Research; Sequencing cost curve; Technology development grants
- National Institute of General Medical Sciences (NIGMS), 3, 4, 37n2, 126, 127, 296
- National Institutes of Health (NIH): All of Us program (Precision Medicine Initiative), 218, 273–74; ARRA funding received by, 81; calls for funding and data use from large-scale projects, 473; Collins as director of, xxiii, 186; Common Fund Programs, 86, 493; communication with international agencies, 28; Consensus Development Conference, 234; DOE collaboration with, 6–7, 14, 17, 30, 35, 126; GenBank, 24, 250–51, 253, 270, 471, 480; Genomic Data Sharing Policy, 236; grants awarded by, 6–7, 16–18, 29–30, 45; Healy as director of, xvii, xxvii, 10–11; political appointment of directors, 10; on public health disparities, 294–95, 307–8; racial issues deliberated by, 294–95, 311n4; research participant guidance from, xxxvii; restructuring under Trump administration, xliii; RoadMap Epigenomics Project, 80, 82, 86, 89, 154; Varmus as director of, 11, 444; Wyngaarden as director of, 4, 42. See also Human Genome Project
- National Institutes of Health Revitalization Act of 1993, 297–98
- National Research Council (NRC), 8, 13–15, 36, 125, 228, 252, 298
- National Science Foundation (NSF), 109, 296
- Native Americans, 111, 115, 298, 300, 306, 307
- Nature (journal): data availability and release policies, 148–51; draft sequence published by, xxxix, xl, 145, 150–51, 160–63, 177, 187, 191n3, 264, 479; editors’ role in shaping publications, 146–47; ENCODE papers published in, 77–78, 153–54; genome papers freely available through, 151–52; at “International Data Release Meeting,” 149; microarray data standards and, 147–48; mission statement for, 145–46; relationship with genomics field, 145, 151, 155; supplementary data policy used by, 152–53; TCGA Project publications in, 153, 443, 445; “thread” innovation and, 78, 153–55
- Nature Genetics (journal), 153, 302–3, 308, 311n3
- NCBI (National Center for Biotechnology Information), 10, 111, 116, 488
- NCDs (noncommunicable diseases), 348, 370n6
- NCHGR. See National Center for Human Genome Research (NCHGR)
- NCI. See National Cancer Institute
- Nègre, N., 433–34n22
- Next-generation sequencing (NGS) platforms: biobanks and, 275; cost point per genome and, 209; ENCODE and, 87–88; sequencing cost curve and, 46, 49, 54–59, 66; TCGA Project and, 445; technology development grants for, 134
- NHGRI. See National Human Genome Research Institute
- NIGMS. See National Institute of General Medical Sciences
- NIH. See National Institutes of Health
- Nitromed, 309, 313n22
- Noncommunicable diseases (NCDs), 348, 370n6
- NRC. See National Research Council
- NSF (National Science Foundation), 109, 296
- Nutritional epigenetics, 354–55
- Office for Human Genome Research (OHGR): creation of, 37n2; evolution into NCHGR, 3, 37n2, 43, 139n1; Jordan as deputy director of, 127; Watson as director of, 165, 188. See also Human Genome Project; National Center for Human Genome Research (NCHGR); National Human Genome Research Institute
- Office of Technology Assessment, 8, 42, 125, 228
- Oliver, S. G., 220
- Olson, Maynard, xviii–xix, 21, 166–67, 183, 251, 255–56, 260–62
- 1000 Genomes Project: community consultation in, 116, 119, 239–40; comprehensive aims of, xli–xlii; cost point per genome for, 212, 222–23n7; Data Coordination Center for, 119; ELSI Program and, 240; Genetic Variation Program and, 118–20; Genome-Wide Association Studies and, 118, 120; haplotypes and, 119, 120; objections to, 222–23n7; race and, xxxi, 293; research questions associated with, 212; selection of populations for inclusion in, 119; single nucleotide polymorphisms and, 119–20; supplementary information document from main paper on, 152; technology development and, 63; tracking of data production from, 59; working groups for, 119
- Optical mapping, 137–38, 219
- Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT), 49, 66, 139, 219
- Pacific Biosciences, 49, 66, 137, 219
- Palazzo, A. F., 422
- Pan-Cancer Atlas project, 447, 448
- Panofsky, Aaron, 310, 312n10, 323
- Parolini, Giuditta, 165
- Past-present ambiguity, 411, 413, 427
- Patents: Bermuda Principles and, 9; cooperative agreements and, 45; ELSI Program and, 231; for expressed sequence tags, xvii, 10, 182, 185; HapMap Project and, 117; Venter on, 182, 185, 195n24; Watson on, xvii, 10, 479
- PDR (Polymorphism Discovery Resource), 110–12, 299–300, 312n12
- Pearson, Peter, 173
- Personalized medicine, xxix, 268, 271, 274, 276, 382
- Pharmacogenomics, xxix, 269, 279, 284–85, 303–5, 309, 313n17
- Phenotypic plasticity, 367, 383–84
- Pheomelanin, 384, 386
- Phillippy, Adam, xl
- Phred scores, 33, 253, 255, 258
- Physical mapping: of C. elegans, 183, 184; chromosome workshops and, 168, 171, 173; circumscription of datasets for, xxxiv; clone libraries for use in, 131; EUROGEM and, 176; GESTEC funding for, 18–19; NRC on desirability of, 13; quality control measures for, 21–22; Sequence-Tagged Sites and, 21, 177; technology development and, 126, 128, 131, 138; of yeast, xviii, 166, 183
- Plomin, Robert, 388–90, 392–93, 395–98
- Polygenic scores, 322, 396–99
- Polymer physics-based studies, 136–38
- Polymorphism Discovery Resource (PDR), 110–12, 299–300, 312n12
- Polymorphisms: absence in simple sequence repeats, 259; errors distinguished from, xxxiv, 250, 251, 254–61; population genetics and, 209, 249; restriction fragment length, 19, 209, 257. See also Single nucleotide polymorphisms
- Population genetics, 109, 208–9, 249, 319
- Postgenomics, xxvi, xxxi–xlii, 163, 189, 340–41
- Precision medicine: African Americans and, 309; biobanks and, 271, 273, 274; continuous medicine and, 275; CSER and ClinGen for, 282; as public health priority, 273–74; research clinics as key sites for, 271, 287; as scientific paradigm, 268, 287–88; TCGA Project and, 443
- Precision Medicine Initiative (All of Us program), 218, 273–74
- Privacy issues: donors and, 116, 118, 299, 300; electronic health records and, 278; genetic records and, xxvii; stored tissue samples and, 236
- Quake, Stephen, 138
- Rabago-Smith, M., 385
- Race, 293–311; in biomedicine, 294, 298, 303, 307, 308, 310–11; conflation of ancestral geography with, 115; continental groupings of, xxix, xxx, 297–99, 306, 310, 312nn7–10; ELSI Program studies on, 299, 301–2, 312–13n13; folk beliefs and categories of, xxx, 238, 239; HapMap Project and, xxxi, 293, 306–7; inclusion in genetic research, 295–302, 305–11, 311n1; intelligence and hierarchy of, 390; 1000 Genomes Project and, xxxi, 293; pharmacogenomics and, 303–5, 309, 313n17; as proxy for human variation, 293, 294, 303; public health disparities and, 294–95, 305, 308, 313n20; reductionistic accounts of, xxviii–xxxii, xliii; US federal taxonomy for, 294–95, 297–99, 305–7, 310, 311n4, 312nn10–11. See also specific racial groups
- Racism: biological effects of, 294, 311, 313n25; genomic medicine and, xxix; HGDP data interpretations and, 298; institutionalized, 384; intelligence and, xxvii, 384, 391; legacy of, xliii, xliv; persistence in genetics and genomics, xliii; scientific, xxviii, xxix, xliii; skin color and, 384, 387
- Reardon, J., xxxi–xxxii
- Rechsteiner, M. C., 480, 481
- Reductionism: causal, 367; definition of, 380; genetic, xxxi, 191, 318, 379, 381–82; HGP and, xxvi, xxviii–xxxi, xxxiii–xxxv, 381; molecular biology and, 380–81; postgenomics as break from, xxxii; race and, xxviii–xxxii, xliii; scientific, 349, 370n10
- Reference Library System, 177, 180
- Reilly, Steven, 329
- Responsible Research and Innovation framework, 331–32
- Restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs), 19, 209, 257
- Reynolds number, 426
- Rheinberger, H.-J., 359, 475, 480
- Ribonucleic acid. See RNA
- Rice, W. R., 320
- Richardson, K., 390
- Richardson, S. S., xxxii
- Riken Institute (Japan), xxix, 191n7
- Risch, Neil, 330
- RNA (ribonucleic acid): isoforms and, 71, 88; messenger, xvii, 482; micro, 420, 448; non-coding, 79, 363, 417, 418; transcription of DNA into, 71, 76, 417, 418
- RoadMap Epigenomics Project, 80, 82, 86, 89, 154
- Rose, N., 361
- Rosenberg, N. A., 397
- Rotimi, Charles, 115, 308, 309
- Roundworm. See Caenorhabditis elegans
- Ruddle, Frank, 168, 169, 172
- Russell, Camisha, xliii
- Rutherford, Ernest, 220, 224n18
- Saccharomyces cerevisiae. See Yeast
- Same-sex sexual behavior: conversion therapies for, 328; genetics of, 318, 320, 322, 328–30; “third sex” concept and, 320. See also Sexual orientation
- Sanger Centre (United Kingdom): establishment of, 184, 479; as G5 sequencing center, 161, 187; HUGO’s divergent approach from, 196n29; research programs in cancer genomics at, 446; SNP Consortium and, 313n18; Wellcome Trust funding of, 7, 184, 195–96n27, 196n30; yeast genome sequencing by, 164, 191n7, 192n9
- SCD (sickle cell disease), 92–93, 299
- Schaffner, K. F., 353
- Schneider, William, 232, 238
- Schwartz, David C., 137–38
- Schwartz, Y. B., 433–34n22
- Science (journal), 75–76, 150–51, 190n2, 293, 300, 318, 330, 479
- Scientific publications, 145–55; author contribution statements in, 147; big data and, 146, 147; consortia-authored papers and, 147, 153–55; data availability and release issues for, 148–51; editors’ role in, 145–47; future outlook for, 155; marker papers and, 84, 88, 90, 94, 149, 449, 451, 453; microarray data and, 147–48; peer review and, 146, 148–49. See also specific publications
- Scientific racism, xxviii, xxix, xliii
- Scientific reductionism, 349, 370n10
- Second-generation sequencing platforms. See Next-generation sequencing (NGS) platforms
- Selected-effects (SE) account of function, 407, 409–14, 416, 431nn6–8
- Sequence-Tagged Sites (STSs), 21, 177, 180
- Sequencing Advisory Committee, 23–24, 26, 36
- Sequencing centers: administration of, 23–24, 26; draft sequence generated by, 25, 27, 160, 161, 191n3; funding for, 7, 25, 33, 46, 161, 166, 184–86, 195–96n27; future outlook for, 221–22; G5, xxxviii, 161–63, 174, 177, 182, 187, 191n3, 195n24; Phred score adopted by, 33; progress reports from, 23, 24, 26, 52–55, 59–61; quality control measures for, 23–24, 33–34; yeast genome sequencing and, 166–67, 192n9. See also Large-Scale Sequencing and Analysis Centers; specific sequencing centers
- Sequencing cost curve, 41–66; actual project costs compared to, 62–63; changes in reporting over periods of large-scale sequencing, 51–61; in commercial vs. research and development setting, 63–64; definition and description of, 41; experience curve effects, 44; future of cost tracking, 65–66; graph components for, 46–51; history of cost estimates and tracking, 42–45; methodological considerations, 46–61; sequencing platforms and, 46, 49, 54–59, 61, 62, 66; success of genomics field represented by, 64–65; technology development and, 41, 50, 51, 53–55, 62
- SES (socioeconomic status), 351, 354, 356–58, 371n11
- Sexual orientation, 318–33; categorization of, 322; discrimination based on, 324–25, 330; fraternal birth order effect and, 321, 322; genetics of, 318, 320–25, 328–33; Genome-Wide Association Studies on, 318, 320–32; maternal immune mechanism and, 321; socially responsible research on, 319–20, 323–25, 328. See also Same-sex sexual behavior
- Shendure, Jay, 87
- Sickle cell disease (SCD), 92–93, 299
- Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs): definition and description of, 112; genetic contribution to disease and, xli; Genome-Wide Association Studies and, 93, 257, 321–22; HapMap Project and, 113–14, 117, 118, 257; linkage disequilibrium and, 113–14, 118, 258; occupational/educational attainment and, xliii; 1000 Genomes Project and, 119–20; variation in, xliii, 112, 254, 258, 260
- Sinsheimer, Robert, 478
- Skin color, genetics of, 386–88
- Skorska, M. N., 321
- Small science, xxxvi, 470–73, 480–81, 483–85, 487, 493
- SNP Consortium, xxxi, 257–58, 293, 305–6, 313n18
- SNPs. See Single nucleotide polymorphisms
- Social epidemiology: definition of, 341, 349–50; historical rise of, 343–45, 348; integration of epigenetics into, 349, 350, 366–68; molecular biology and, 341; “the social” in, 349–53, 358; style of reasoning specific to, 366
- Social epigenetics, 340–42, 353–54
- Social genomics (sociogenomics), xliii, 319, 322, 331
- Social implications of research. See Ethical, Legal, and Social Implications (ELSI) Program
- Socially responsible research, 319–20, 323–25, 328, 331–32
- Socioeconomic status (SES), 351, 354, 356–58, 371n11
- Spencer, Quayshawn, xxx
- Stanford–Binet IQ tests, 392
- Stanford DNA Sequencing and Technology Center, 166, 191n7, 313n18
- Statistical genetics, 109
- Sternberg, Robert, 390
- Stevens, H., xxxii
- Stoddard, Charlotte, 154
- Stored tissue samples, 235–37
- Strasser, B. J., 441, 480, 481
- Stratton, M. R., 455
- Structural genomics, 405, 430n1
- Structural variants (SVs): in cancer genome, 137, 223n9, 451; cost considerations and, 219, 220; in disease architecture, 259, 260; measurement challenges, 250, 251, 254–55, 259, 262; 1000 Genomes Project working group for, 119; single nucleotide polymorphisms and, 112
- STSs (Sequence-Tagged Sites), 21, 177, 180
- Styles of reasoning, 365–66
- Sulston, John, 22–23, 182–87, 195n25, 196n29
- Sussman, Hillary, 154
- SVs. See Structural variants
- Systems biology, 495n8
- Szymanski, Erika, 167
- TCGA Project. See Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) Project, The
- Team science, 20, 446
- Technology development: CEGS program and, 135–36; for counting applications, 222n2; data production and, 130, 139; Department of Energy and, 6, 479; ENCODE and, 73, 77, 82, 85–88, 131; genome mapping and, 126, 128, 131, 138; genome sequencing and, xxii, xxiv, 41, 125–29, 134, 138–39; HGP and, 8, 16, 29, 32, 35, 124–35, 139; multidisciplinary approach to, 125–27; 1000 Genomes Project and, 63; peer review and, 125, 127–28, 133; scientific advances in relation to, 203; sequencing cost curve and, 41, 50, 51, 53–55, 62. See also Next-generation sequencing (NGS) platforms
- Technology development grants, 124–39; calls for proposals for, 126–27; career award program and, 129; criteria for, 128–29; ENCODE and, 87, 131; FOAs for, 126–28, 132–35, 137, 139; GESTECs and, 18–19, 127–30; HGP and, 124, 126–28; investigator-initiated, 132–33, 136, 138; for nanopore sequencing, 138–39; peer review and, 127–28, 133; for polymer physics-based studies, 136–38; for single-molecule sequencing, 138
- Telomere-to-Telomere Consortium (T2T), xxxiii
- Terman, Lewis, 391
- Thalassemia, 92–93, 299
- Thomson, Elizabeth, xxvii, xxxvii, 232, 234
- TIGR (The Institute for Genome Research), 181–82
- TOPMed program (National Heart Lung and Blood Institutes), 216
- Trastuzumab (Herceptin), 284, 446
- Turner, Stephen W., 137
- 23andMe, 273, 284, 324, 330, 332
- United Kingdom: biobank launched in, 271; Human Genome Mapping Project, 177, 180–81, 184; Medical Research Council, 22, 28, 184; Resource Centre, 180–82, 194n22. See also Sanger Centre; Wellcome Trust
- United Nations Educational, Science, and Culture Organization (UNESCO), 298
- University of Tokyo, 192n9
- Washington University Genome Sequencing Center, 119, 161, 166–67, 183–84, 187, 191n7, 313n18, 444
- Wasserman, David, 232
- Waters, C. K., 496n11
- Waterston, Robert, 22–23, 182–87
- Watson, James: on C. elegans genome sequencing, 183, 184, 188; as co-discoverer of DNA structure, 183, 188, 191n5; as CSHL director, 165; Healy’s firing of, xvii; HUGO established by, 7; as OHGR director, 165, 188; paper on complete genome sequence of, 148; in patenting controversy, xvii, 10, 479; proposal for ELSI Program, xxvii, 5, 228; publicity campaign for HGP led by, xxi, 5, 6; recruitment for HGP, 8; on whole-genome sequencing, 159, 172; on yeast genome sequencing, 165–67, 188
- Webb, Watt, 137
- Wedow, Robbee, 324, 333–34n2
- Weinberg, R., 480
- Welch, John, 458, 465n9
- Wellcome Trust (United Kingdom): chromosome workshops sponsored by, 186, 187, 196n30; genome mapping supported by, 159, 172; HapMap Project and, 114; “International Data Release Meeting” sponsored by, 149; NIH communication with, 28; racial diversity initiatives, 309; sequencing centers funded by, 7, 33, 161, 184–86, 195–96n27
- Wexler, Nancy, 7
- White, D., 385
- Whitehead Institute, 161, 187, 313n18
- Women: inclusion in genetic research, 294, 297, 299; maternal immune mechanism in, 321; task forces on health of, 295. See also Gender
- World Health Organization, 370n6
- Wyngaarden, James, 4, 10, 42
- Zinder, Norton, 8